top of page

Settling the Debate Over the “Great American Novel?”

1 day ago
5 min read

My candidates for the Great American Novel lined up. Each of these books is not only excellent, but features great cover art. Photo Credits: Isaac James


Isaac James, Community Desk Lead for The Powderhorn


The “Great American Novel,” often abbreviated as GAN, is a source of constant debate. The idea itself comes from an essay by the somewhat obscure American author John William De Forest, and concerns the existence of a book that encapsulates the spirit of the United States as a cultural entity, both at its best and its worst. While De Forest himself thought the Great American Novel had not yet been written, nearly two centuries later, numerous novels have been put forward as candidates.  


Of the novelists most often associated with the title are greats like John Steinbeck, Mark Twain, Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, William Faulkner, and more recently authorial heavyweights like Toni Morrison and Harper Lee. 


While there are hundreds of possible books one could make a case for, from my own reading I’ve whittled it down to a list of the five strongest candidates, number five being, comparatively, the weakest, and one being the strongest. 


5. “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn” 

Betty Smith’s 1943 classic “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn” is not often or historically at the top of GAN lists. However, Smith’s masterpiece has been the topic of contemporary debate, with many believing it deserves at least consideration for the title. A coming-of-age story, the novel focuses on the life of a young girl in early-1900s Brooklyn. The work itself comprises 5 books, each focusing on either main character Francie Nolan or her parents and chronicling her upbringing in the city.


The story itself is one of poverty, neglect, and hardship, but also of perseverance and growth. The book’s ahead-of-the-time portrayal of class and gender divides in 20th Century America made it controversial but also deeply relatable for young women in particular. 


I read the book in 9th grade, and the themes of growing up, adolescence, and the potential of education continue to resonate with me, especially in the transition from high school. What makes the book such a great GAN candidate is its alternative lens on American culture. From the perspective of a poor young girl, Smith explores American idealism from an unconventional and important perspective. 


4. “The Sound and the Fury” 


William Faulkner’s magnum opus “The Sound and the Fury” is arguably the most challenging novel on this list. The book is written in stream-of-consciousness style, meaning the text is meant to mirror the character’s inner thoughts as they come, with little to no conventional structure. This style is typical to many modernist writers, who experimented heavily with fragmented, nonlinear structure to explore the human psyche. In “The Sound and the Fury,” Faulkner separates the book into four sections, each from the perspective of a different person involved with the fictional Compson family of Mississippi. 


The core of the story revolves around a family tragedy, each section reflecting the effects of the tragedy on each of the four narrators. The first section is told from the perspective of the Compson family’s youngest son Benjy, who has an intellectual disability. This part of the book is the most challenging, as the mix of the stream-of-consciousness style with Benjy’s lack of temporal awareness makes the jumps between different dates incredibly hard to follow. As the novel progresses, each section gets gradually easier to read as the reader grows more accustomed to the prose. Additionally, the style of writing changes in each section, getting closer to conventionality.


The story’s message about the American South, the downfall of southern aristocracy and the consequences of the past make it not only effective as a family story but also as a reflection of the United States in general. 


3. “Blood Meridian”


Cormac McCarthy’s 1985 landmark novel “Blood Meridian” is by technicality a Western, but many consider it to be the quintessential “anti-Western,” a critique of the brutality and inhumanity of the American West in the 19th Century. 


The story itself centers around a protagonist known only as “The Kid,” a runaway adolescent from Tennessee who finds himself among the ranks of a scalping gang in the Southwest. The leader of the gang is John Joel Glanton, a real historical figure who ran a similar gang of his own. Much of the book is based in history, with McCarthy borrowing many of the story’s more realistic details from the memoir of Samuel Chamberlain, a member of Glanton’s gang. One of the most captivating parts of McCarthy’s prose is his use of archaic, often biblical language to describe the vast and beautiful landscapes of the West amidst the bloodshed. 


The main antagonist of the story is the terrifying Judge Holden. Described as more than 7 feet tall, completely hairless, and white as a sheet, he occupies that area between realistic and supernatural that can be so deeply chilling. 


“Blood Meridian” is unflinching, cruel and brutally honest. Deviating from the typical romantic portrayal of the western frontier, the story provides a look into the depravity of that time and place. In American media, the western frontier is too often treated as the land of cowboys and duels, but “Blood Meridian” shows the importance of understanding the ugly, concealed truth. For this reason, “Blood Meridian” is an undoubtedly important and revolutionary work in the world of westerns and earns its spot in the greatest American novels.


2. “Beloved” 


“Mesmerizing,” “wonderful,” and “shattering.” All of these are words used in praise for Toni Morrison’s masterwork, “Beloved.” For me it was haunting in all the right ways. The book won the 1988 Pulitzer Prize and was the driving piece behind Morrison’s 1993 Nobel Prize in Literature. To say this acclaim is due would be an understatement. 


“Beloved” tackles America’s most pervasive and shameful history, chattel slavery. The story revolves around a formerly-enslaved woman Sethe, her daughter Denver, and the ghost of her never-named infant child. Principal to the novel are the themes of slavery’s lasting impacts, the pain of memory and motherly love. 


The depictions of Sethe and others’ time under the institution of slavery are deeply upsetting and emotional. Morrison is remarkable in her ability to describe the depravity and moral corruption of those behind Sethe’s captivity. Some of the scenes will leave readers visibly uncomfortable, upset and shocked at the all-too-real history behind the novel’s events.


We cannot meaningfully discuss the history and culture of the United States without mention of the horrific institution of slavery. “Beloved” does this in a way so impactful that it makes it an absolute must for any list of the Great American novels, and is one of the most remarkable books I’ve read in my lifetime. 


1. “East of Eden”


Rounding out the list at the top is the great John Steinbeck’s masterpiece “East of Eden.” The novel is an epic in every sense of the word. At its core, “East of Eden” is a family story, spanning decades on each side of the American continent. 


I’ve written a review for “East of Eden” as a standalone piece, which you can find here, but the long and short of the book is the power of choice and the complexity of family, all loosely based around a retelling of Cain and Abel. 


What makes the novel such an exceptional choice for the title of Great American Novel is its exploration of the human character through life in America. The reader follows most of the characters as they grow up, experiencing hardship and triumph along the backdrop of a growing and changing nation. The message that Steinbeck delivers about human potential and the capacity for good makes it deeply affecting and, for me, the Great American Novel. 


Comments


CONTACT US

Thanks for submitting!

SUBSCRIBE

Subscribe for updates and notifcations

Thanks for submitting!

Blue White Simple Website Survey Google Form Header.png

WHS Journalism / The Powderhorn
attn: Adrienne Stumb
300 Go Pioneers Drive
Room 3108
Boone, NC 28607

© Watauga Publishing

bottom of page